Skip to main content
Birthdays, Holidays, CelebrationsThanksgiving

The Only Thanksgiving Guide You Need

By November 5, 2013November 12th, 2013814 Comments

Last year, we devoted a lot of blog space to Thanksgiving, by Sam Sifton. And since weโ€™re editors and writers, supposedly on the pulse of what the lastest, greatest, trendiest everything is, we should probably be featuring this yearโ€™s of-the-moment holiday cookbook. But hereโ€™s the thing: โ€œtrendyโ€ and โ€œof-the-momentโ€ are not words that should EVER EVER EVER be in the same sentence as โ€œThanksgiving,โ€ and we stand by our claim that Sam Siftonโ€™s timeless, authoritative, delicious guide to our countryโ€™s greatest holiday is The Only Thanksgiving Recipe Collection You Will Ever Need. (Outside of your grandmotherโ€™s recipe box, of course โ€” we donโ€™t want to get anyone in trouble here). As such, we launch our โ€œCountdown to Thanksgiving Seriesโ€ with a bountiful giveaway: In the next 48 hours, five readers are eligible to win a free copy of Siftonโ€™s Thanksgiving, and five more are eligible to have a free copy sent to whoever is cooking/hosting the feastโ€ฆ as a little pre-holiday pump-up and thank-you-in-advance. Thatโ€™s TEN COPIES WE ARE GIVING AWAY. All you have to do is leave a comment below (we wouldnโ€™t complain if this comment included a Thanksgiving tip) and tell me which one you are: #Host or #Guest.

Update: All winners have been notified. Congrats Josh, Betsy, Candice, Eva, Molly, Susan, Colleen F, L, Divya, Memegirl and to everyone else thanks for playing!

Related: Sam Siftonโ€™s 1o Laws of Thanksgiving.

814 Comments

  • Avatar Katie Hansen says:

    Iโ€™m a heavily involved guest โ€“ my big tips are do the Kitchn make ahead gravy and Pioneer womanโ€™s mashed potatoes, and do a fun dessert or appetizer to stay creative. Itโ€™s also a fun time to bust out a classic veggie side that screams special occasion โ€“ once I did Julia Childโ€™s creamed spinach. It was a hit and I had extra laborers to help me stem it.

  • Avatar Memegrl says:

    Not hosting but my host would love this!
    No tips, alas, but I have really enjoyed everyone elseโ€™s!

  • Ariane says:

    Great giveaway! My tip: have Thanksgiving on the day after. Way less stressful and allows plenty of travel time for visiting family.

  • Avatar Margit Van Schaickmargit says:

    Iโ€™ll be a guest. But, on the week-end my daughter and her husband and one-year-old son will come and I will then be hosting them for a turkey pot pie, which they can take plenty of left-overs home, to freeze lunch-size portions for the work week. Also some apple and pumpkin pie.

  • Tracy says:

    I love to have my kids make up family trivia to play while they are waiting for dinner to start. The prize is to get to eat the first piece of pie.

  • Avatar Andi says:

    Two tips: set up a bar/drink and snack station away from the kitchen, and add cream cheese to mashed potatoes.

  • Avatar Andi says:

    #HOST Two tips: set up a bar/drink and snack station away from the kitchen, and add cream cheese to mashed potatoes.

  • Avatar Claire H. says:

    Host! Well, my momโ€™s house is the roof since weโ€™re up to 16 this year (ulp) but I am List Maker, Decider and Maker of almost everything but the turkey. Oh, this lists this year are glorious, glorious, I tell ya! But weโ€™ve never settled on a repeat stuffing recipe so the quest continuesโ€ฆ

  • Avatar Kath the Cook says:

    Iโ€™m the cook. Lots of work but I enjoy it. You guys rock! Canโ€™t do without the leftovers! Thatโ€™s why you canโ€™t go to anybody elseโ€™s house. I want (earlier commenter) โ€˜Martaโ€™ to bring the pies!

  • Avatar Laura Christine says:

    We always have a big meal with several families combined plus anyone we know who needs a home for Thanksgiving. After many years of this, my Thanksgiving tip would be to remember to share the joy with those who are missing their loved ones. #Guest

  • Avatar Wendy says:

    Iโ€™m a guest this year; Iโ€™ll probably be in charge of bringing a side dish to each of the two celebrations weโ€™ll attend. Last year, on sort of a whim, I tried making Brussels sprouts for the first timeโ€“theyโ€™re destined to become a tradition, I think!

  • Morgan says:

    #guest at my dear mamaโ€™s house. I will be making pie!

  • Avatar Holly Estes says:

    I am guest hosting!

  • Avatar Sam says:

    Iโ€™m a guest at my parents for a much hoped-for holiday weekend. Something my mom always does is offer a non-pie/non-pumpkin dessert for people looking to try something different (or to leave me with a sweet breakfast for the next morningโ€ฆ Shhhh โ€“ donโ€™t tell I had dessert for breakfast ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Avatar Jessy says:

    Iโ€™m a #guest flying in from far away. The people at the table definitely make the meal, and the more the merrier (just as long as we all pitch in to help the host!).

  • Avatar Emily says:

    #host. My mother asked to come to my house instead this yearโ€ฆ.sheโ€™s tired of cooking for a crowd. As someone who cooks for groups of 15+ at least twice a week, she sure deserves a break! My advice: have a few sofas reserved for napping areas after the feast. ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Avatar sarapete says:

    My tip is to assign people a specific dish to bring. No surprises and you can plan the meal accordiingly.

  • Avatar Jenn says:

    Iโ€™m guest and host. We host a friend Thanksgiving potluck the week before so we can have/share our quintessential dishes, and then my parents host on the day and I feel no need to controls anything. I have it out of our system. I would love to have Samโ€™s book.

  • Avatar Jenn says:

    Iโ€™m guest and host. We host a friend Thanksgiving potluck the week before so we can have/share our quintessential dishes, and then my parents host on the day and I feel no need to control anything. I have it out of our system. I would love to have Samโ€™s book.

  • Avatar Erica Rawson says:

    My mom is hosting (as usual)!!! I am #guest

  • Avatar Rachel says:

    If spending the day with your mother in law who drives you crazy (and tries feeding your 5 month old a grape), know when to step away and lock yourself in your room, or a bathroom, for 5 minutes so you donโ€™t rip her head off in front of everyone else (after taking away the grape).

  • Avatar E.R.C. says:

    Hope my local library has this book.

  • Divya says:

    Iโ€™m hosting this Thanksgiving! For the first time, and I am nervousโ€ฆ.so this book (and the tips from everyone) are really helping.

    My tip: (or at least what I plan to do) is to prep a few days in advance. Have a list of to do items for 3 days before, 2 days before, 1 day before, and day of Thanksgiving.

    I would love this book Jenny.
    Also, I LOVE your blog!

    Divya
    #host

  • Avatar rebecca says:

    #guest.
    Prepping as much in advance as possible, and donโ€™t be afraid to make guests wash dishes!

Leave a Reply

What is 11 + 3 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)