Skip to main content
Books, Gifts, CultureDomestic AffairsPosts by Andy

Let There Be Rock

By September 28, 2011February 1st, 201733 Comments

I spent fifteen years after high school pretending Led Zeppelin sucked. I was apparently too cool forย Everybody Knows This is Nowhere. Something happened to me when I went off to college โ€“ well, a lot of things happened to me when I went off to college, but the most egregious was that I stopped rocking my a*s off. Not that I was ever in a band or anything. The closest I came to actual shredding was air-guitaring to โ€œWhole Lotta Rosieโ€ with my Arthur Ashe tennis racket in the paneled family room of our house in the suburbs of Northern Virginia. But college messed me up. Suddenly, music, like the books I pretended to read (waddup, Gรผnter Grass?!) under trees on the quad, had become social currency, a signifier of intellectual heft. Suddenly, I was into the Cure and the Cocteau Twins, 10,000 Maniacs,ย and a moody Scottish troubador who called himself Lloyd Cole. I took long hangover naps to the gentle strains of Talk Talk. I DJโ€™d a radio show and inflicted Jesus Jones on the poor souls of Western Massachusetts, whose only crime was turning on their radios on Saturday morning, hoping to hear music. By the time I graduated, I was afloat in a warm bath of ambience and interesting lyrics.

A brief history of my descent, from there: In the late nineties, Jenny and I got married, and in the inevitable process of accommodation and compromise, my musical tastes changed again โ€” Lucinda Williams, Matthew Sweet, Norah (gulp) Jones, Sheryl (double gulp) Crow, Ryan Adams, and many others Iโ€™ve no doubt repressed โ€“ and the soundtrack of my life down-shifted into what I call Music Couples Can Cook To. Then came kids, and Iโ€™ll spare you the grisly account of how my iPod was violated over the five year period that my kids were becoming sentient beings, but letโ€™s just say that I know a few songs by Laurie Berkner. If we ventured outside of kid music during these years, it was into territory that felt family-friendly and safe yet still adult, that โ€“ if deployed in a car traveling at 60 mph โ€“ could lull a cranky child to sleep. In other words, weโ€™d moved into the Music That Wonโ€™t Ruin Dinner Parties phase of life. This was thoughtful, smart stuff, sung by dudes in skinny jeans; this was literature set to music. And I participated, suffering through Bright Eyes, M. Ward, Andrew Bird, Jenny Lewis, Jeff Tweedy (solo), Neko Case, Elvis Perkins, andโ€ฆholy crap, I nearly fell asleep just typing that list.

Then, in 2006, I was saved.

One day at work, a friend handed me a copy of the newly-remasteredย Live at the Fillmore East by Neil Young and Crazy Horse. I put it on at my desk, and in the course of the COMPLETELY BRAIN-MELTING SIXTEEN MINUTE AND NINE SECOND VERSION of โ€œCowgirl in the Sandโ€ that ensued, something powerful rose up from the depths. It was like having spent ten years watching decent high schoolers play pepper, and then going to batting practice at Yankee Stadium.ย Oh, right. So THIS is how itโ€™s done. The shock of recognition, the glimpse of your old, pre-kid, pre-married, less Starbucks-y self: that stuff is for real. I donโ€™t want to overstate things, but something awoke within me that day, some long-lost part of the old me who enjoyed a gratuitous guitar solo and didnโ€™t feel like wearing a scarf or being bummed out. Interesting lyrics are interesting, but Iโ€™m borderline middle-aged, with a full-time job and two daughters and a gray crossover vehicle, and I could use something more thanย interesting. Down the rabbit hole I went, digging up old CDs, trolling youtube for jams, burning tons of Stones and James Brown and Led Zeppelin , ditching the singer-songwriters and diving deep into anything that sounded good loud, from the three-guitar onslaught of The Drive-By Truckers to Jack White to โ€œCheck Your Headโ€-era Beasties to My Morning Jacket to The Jam to, yes, Duane Fโ€™ing Allman. And hereโ€™s the thing: For the most part, the kids came right along with me. I started playing this stuff in the car, on the way to soccer games and playdates โ€“ and with rare exceptions (see: Burma, Mission Of), I heard very few complaints. Instead, I heard, when the song ended: โ€œAgain.โ€ Instead, I saw, in the rear view mirror, during those first thirty seconds of โ€œCustard Pieโ€: Abby, her window down and her hair blowing back, doing her guitar face. She couldnโ€™t have looked happier. Because kids, instinctively, know what feels good. Donโ€™t believe me? Put on some Mason Jennings, and then put on โ€œHotel Yorba,โ€ and turn it up. See what sticks. โ€” Andy

Rock & Roll Illustration by Phoebe.

33 Comments

  • Avatar elsewise says:

    Have you seen the documentary โ€œIt Might Get Loudโ€? Itโ€™s a look at guitars, rock history, and music, through interviews (and a jam session!) with Jack White, The Edge, and Jimmy Page. HIGHLY enjoyable. Even potentially safe for a wee rock fan.

  • Avatar emily says:

    Another entry for Music Couples Can Cook To: David Gray!
    This is so true. And scarily resonant.

  • Avatar Tom H. says:

    Great post, Andy! Weโ€™ve been finding that the Tedeschi Trucks Band rocks everyoneโ€™s socks off โ€“ Revelator is their latest, greatest album.

  • Avatar Tara says:

    The language factor is what gets us. Love The Beastie Boys, esp. Check Your Head, but itโ€™s the f-bomb that keeps it solely on the iPod shuffle we use exclusively for working outโ€ฆ with headphones. Same goes for Rage Against the Machine, although, really, who am I kidding? Itโ€™s not for nothinโ€™ that a good friend said of Rage: โ€œI donโ€™t know what the f*** that guy is saying, but whatever it is, itโ€™s right on!โ€

    Some older stuff from The Frames (esp. Fitzcarraldo and Dance the Devil) have been great discoveries to fill the โ€œI want good music that rocks, but that doesnโ€™t teach the kids words I donโ€™t want them using around their grandparentsโ€ void. Thereโ€™re only a few lyrics I have to remember to talk loudly over in the car.

    One of our familyโ€™s whole family sing along albums is Cakeโ€™s Comfort Eagle. And Los Lobosโ€™ Colossal Head and The Town and The City are big faves, too.

  • Avatar David says:

    No way! During all those dreary winter nights in Garman, I was sure I was the only guy at Amherst listening to Lloyd Cole.

  • Avatar Susie says:

    Our kids are subjected to more Green Day than should be legal. Explicit lyrics and all. And when my little one was 2.5 and we tossed the ipad into his crib on a hungover Saturday morning he had found the music app and started cranking it himself. We smiled and rolled over.

  • andy says:

    Elsewise โ€” yes, I saw that, and loved that. Loved that moment when Jimmy Page was air-guitaring to โ€œRumbleโ€ and basically turned into a kid again: fantastic.

  • Avatar Natalie says:

    Some of my favorite childhood memories are of driving up north, head in my dadโ€™s lap under the steering wheel and feet on my mom, rocking out with my dadโ€™s classic tunes. I knew almost every word on Eric Claptonโ€™s Crossroads before I was in first grade. I listen to all kinds of stuff now, but The Doors, Jimi and CCR still hold special places in my shuffle rotation, and I always attribute my love of music to the awesome stuff my parents exposed me to when I was younger.

  • jenny jenny says:

    I think this may be my most favorite Post by Andy ever.

  • Avatar Ginger says:

    Loved Lloyd Coleโ€ฆ just sayinโ€™

  • Anna says:

    we named our son hendrix. while i hate to admit it i donโ€™t mind some of the music that wonโ€™t ruin dinner parties. my fiance, mike, canโ€™t stand it. he can often be found playing led zepplin and jimmy hendrix youtube videos for our son.
    the kid loves it, but also would only sleep to andrew birdโ€™s armchair acpocrypha from 4 -9 months of age. which is why mike says andrew bird makes music for babies.
    letโ€™s hope hendrix gets his fatherโ€™s taste in music because letโ€™s face it. . .it rocks way more. great post, andy.

  • Avatar erika says:

    Great post! Our 19-month old daughter is now into James Brown, and will even mimic his growling screams. She likes the Black Keys too โ€“ really, anything with a solid beat!

  • Avatar jo says:

    i love โ€œhotel yorbaโ€ and led zeppelin, but iโ€™m unabashedly in love with andrew bird, neko case, and m. ward. just because they have amazingly thoughtful lyrics doesnโ€™t mean they canโ€™t rock a little bit, too. ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Jason says:

    I feel so happy when my 7 y.o. asks to hear โ€œTestifyโ€ by Parliament a second time. Then, when she asks to hear Kidzbop 18 for the thousandth time, I want to jam a chopstick in my ear.

  • John says:

    A friend passed this blog post on to me and I loved it. Iโ€™m with Jo re M Ward, Neko, Andrew Bird (though I had to LOL at Annaโ€™s riff on Bird). Iโ€™m guessing most of us like a lot of different stuff. Weโ€™re just living more complicated lives, so itโ€™s not always easy to get in the mood to cook and get the Led out. Not that I havenโ€™t done that. It just tends to be when Iโ€™m cooking on my own. Also, um, letโ€™s just say adult beverages can be a factor in what goes into the rotation and how much air guitar gets played. ๐Ÿ˜‰

  • Avatar mek says:

    Our kid has always been partial to funk โ€“ kept the crying-in-the-car to a minimum when she was a baby, discovered by accident thanks to the Twin Cities awesome The Current radio station.

    Somehow she then turned into a kid who would like to play the accordion, the ukulele, or the bagpipes. (We bought the uke.)

  • Avatar Chris says:

    Hilarious. I sing Sweet Child Of Mine and The Gambler to my 3 and 2 year olds to sleep. They love it.

    Also Chantilly Lace by Big Bopper

  • Avatar Vicki says:

    As I watched a 60 year old Sting (thatโ€™s right 60) being interviewed today on Morning Joe, I was immediately launched back into my dorm room circa 1983. Seriously, The Police, talk about awesome music.

    I am with you Andy, get the kids hooked early on good music. We are hard core Springsteen fans here. I play โ€œThe Wild, the Innocent and the E Street Shuffleโ€ for my kids. By sheer osmosis they are starting to like/know his musicโ€ฆ.ahhh!

  • Elizabeth says:

    My fifth grader just convinced his classmates to call themselves The Woodstocks and that wasnโ€™t the Peanuts character. Weโ€™re proud. ๐Ÿ™‚

    And thanks for the heads up on Hotel Yorba. I hadnโ€™t ever listened to it โ€” wow.

  • Avatar Susan says:

    For those of you looking for great music in Westchester try 107.1 FM, The Peak (or stream it at 1071thepeak.com). They play a lot of what you mention above.

    It is the only station my 5-year-old and I listen to both in the car and at home.

    Full disclosure, I happen to be the Program Directorโ€™s wife, but even if I werenโ€™t, my 5-year-old and I would still listen constantly. Although we probably wouldnโ€™t call into the station as much when we like certain songs ๐Ÿ™‚

  • Avatar km says:

    Love this post. My trajectory was this
    Depeche Mode, Flock of Seagulls , (loved Llyold Cole), etc etc. High School- we were British Isleโ€™rs so this was relatively mainstream
    college was Jethro Tull, Donovan and yes Neil Young.
    Cleaning the apartment with the windows open singing at the top of voice Janice Joplin.
    Adult
    ipod showed severe schizophrenia. And yes,Guns and Roses turned up.
    Now, I am introducing my kids to Queen. Queen, my 10 year old self has returned.

  • Julienne says:

    This is a fantastic post. Well said on so many levels. The funny thing is that I love all the music you trash. But your perspective is gold and your writing spot-on.

  • Avatar 654carroll says:

    how could you possibly have spent any time in Amherst, Mass., and *not* listened the sh*t out of Everybody Knows This is Nowhere?

    On the Adult Dinner Party tip: Did Rick Rubin make something like four albums of tepid covers by Johnny Cash, and was I really chump enough to buy all four of them?

  • Andy says:

    654: I have no excuses, only regrets. And come on: Johnny Cash doing Neil Diamond is good! All these suggestions are great, so I will begin loading the iPod. Thanks.

  • Avatar rental mobil says:

    Very nice, thanks for sharing.

Leave a Reply

What is 12 + 14 ?
Please leave these two fields as-is:
IMPORTANT! To be able to proceed, you need to solve the following simple math (so we know that you are a human) :-)